THOUGHTS ABOUT PERSUASION OF CONSERVATIVE JURORS
The October 2026 American Association for Justice issue of Trial Magazine was focused on the subject of Persuasion and Juror Bias. One section involved an interview with Robert Hirshhorn, a well known Jury consultant. What follows are some of the points that he made about the subject of dealing with persuasion of Conservative jurors.
- In Donald Trump’s first presidential campaign, no matter how people felt about his message, his delivery was undeniably effective. His language was simple, direct, and highly accessible to most people and often delivered at about a 4th grade level. On the other hand, lawyers have a habit of over complicating language and failing to connect with jurors, especially conservative ones.
- Conservative jurors are less impressed by credentials and more persuaded by real world experience. Beginning direct examination with an expert’s list of education and degrees may actually weaken an experts credibility. Conservative jurors are less impressed by credentials and more persuaded by real world experience, especially those who value earned experience over teaching.
- Lawyers struggle to connect with conservative jurors because they’re speaking the wrong language. They should use value based language like “ignoring a known risk” or “ breaking safety rules.” Saying the product was “defective” is less powerful than saying “the company placed the product on the market before it was safe.”
- Lawyers should use language which engages conservative jurors & language that communicates shared values. When used correctly, they create an alignment with the jurors, build trust and form bonds. For example, “taking responsibility,” “Individual freedoms,” and active words like “protect” and “save” connect with these Conservative jurors.
- The biggest mistake is treating conservative jurors as one group. For instance, financial conservatives are concerned about lower taxes and reduced spending. Libertarians focus on maximizing individual freedom to make their own choices. Religious conservatives place emphasis on preserving moral and religious traditions.
- The most powerful way for building rapport with conservative jurors is to reflect the conservative jurors values, beliefs and even clothing. Clothing can be important in making a first impression. People trust people who feel and resemble themselves. Identify what matters to conservatives and connect the case to those values.
- Lawyers should stop thinking in terms of liberal versus conservative and instead think in terms of human needs. Every juror, regardless of ideology, wants to feel respected, understood and connected. They care about fairness, family, responsibility, and community. Those are universal needs and values.
While some of these points may seem obvious, the fact is that too often lawyers forget to put these into practice with a jury. These ideas about conservative jurors apply equally to all jurors. They are effective because humans make emotional decisions first, then use cognitive dissonance to rationalize them. We all like to believe we’re rational, but we rely on our emotions far more than we are willing to admit, even to ourselves. There is power in making an emotional case first and counting on people rationalizing it later. Trump’s messaging often favored vivid mental images, memorable nicknames, and extreme simplicity over complex, making his ideas easy to absorb and repeat.